Provider Network Complaints Get Buried

PG168160

The good news is, I finally received some of the provider network consumer complaints that I asked for from the Ohio Department of Insurance.

The bad news is, for many of the complaints, we don’t get to know the outcome because the Ohio Department of Insurance kicks the complaint over to another department, and they make it confidential. The following are paragraphs from the Ohio insurance department’s closing letters for various provider network complaints:

Due to this error we are referring our findings to another division within the Department for further review. Please be aware that investigations by this division and the records pertaining to these investigations are confidential by law. Consequently, the Department will not be able to provide you with any information as to whether an active case investigation will be opened on the matter or if an active case investigation is opened and the status of the investigation.
Based upon our review of the facts and circumstances presented, we determined that CareSource provided you inaccurate information regarding their provider network. The Department is also concerned about the likelihood that additional members have received inaccurate network information as well. Therefore, this matter has been referred to another division in our agency for investigation.
Due to incorrect information provided to you by Buckeye, we have forwarded our findings to another division within the Department for further review. Please be aware that investigations by this division are confidential by law. Consequently, the Department will not be able to provide you with any information as to whether an active case investigation will be open on the matter you reported or if an active case investigation is opened and the status of the investigation.
Caresource did not initially administer the claim in accordance with the terms of your policy; therefore, we have forwarded our findings to another division within our Department for further review. Please be aware that investigations by this division and the records pertaining to these investigations are confidential by law. Consequently, the Department will not be able to provide you with any information as to whether an active case investigation will be opened on the matter you reported or if an active case investigation is opened and the status of any investigation.
We have forwarded our findings to another division within our Department for further review. Please be aware that investigations by this division are confidential by law. Consequently, the Department will not be able to provide you with any information as to whether an active case investigation will be opened on the matter you reported, or the status if an investigation is opened.

What is the law that they claim prevents them from revealing the status or results of the investigation? The new provider network rules they put into place this year. They wrote in a clause that gives them the power to keep investigations confidential.

http://codes.ohio.gov/oac/3901-8-16

(2) All documents provided to the superintendent under paragraph (G) of this rule shall be considered work papers of the superintendent that are subject to section 3901.48 of the Revised Code and are confidential and privileged and shall not be considered a public record, as defined in section 149.43 of the Revised Code. The original documents and any copies of them shall not be subject to subpoena and shall not be made public by the superintendent or any other person, except as otherwise provided in section 3901.48 of the Revised Code.

Clever!  So all of our provider network complaints get buried. Companies get to keep doing this, because the Ohio Department of Insurance doesn’t care. They reward them instead, with confidentiality. And after two years, they destroy the original complaint, buried, burned, deleted.

I told you they are run by the insurance guy!

PG168109

Related: Ohio Citizen Rate Review Provider Network Survey, Summer 2016

Related: Passing the Buck: My letter to complaint examiner

3 thoughts on “Provider Network Complaints Get Buried

  1. Join http://Healthcare-now.org and your state’s single payer organization to advocate to get insurance companies out of the healthcare business. We don’t need a choice of insurance, we need freedom to go to providers we want not those in a network. see also Physicians for a National Health Program for more resources. Spread the word to anyone you can about H.R. 676 Improved Medicare For All. We are the only industrialized nation without universal healthcare. Why not? Follow the money.
    See FIXITHealthcare.com, TheHealthcareMovie.net, etc. search YouTube for single payer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *